LisaList2

General Category => LisaList2 => Lisa Troubleshooting and Repair => Topic started by: bmwcyclist on November 16, 2026, 09:01:18 AM

Title: Lisa 2/10: SYSTEM ERROR 10590 that follows one CPU board. Suggestions?
Post by: bmwcyclist on November 16, 2026, 09:01:18 AM
My Lisa 2/10 bombs with SYSTEM ERROR 10590 (memory parity) after anywhere from a few minutes to an hour of use. The CPU board is assembly 820-4009-B with H boot ROMs.

At first I assumed it was a RAM issue but changing out all of the RAM boards had no effect.

What did change things is swapping out the CPU board from my other LISA. That fixed it but I need to get the bad CPU board running or replaced to have both going.

There are only 2 socketed chips on the CPU board. I thought sure it was going to be the VIDEO ROM as some of the errors seemed to imply that might be related. I happened to have a VintageMicros VideoROM (to get the office number) that I never installed. I put it in, and the errors seemed to change slightly, but no fix.

I replaced the CPU and still no fix.

So things are not looking good, everything else is not socketed....

So the fault follows my CPU board. Both memory board types, both video ROMs and both 68000s are cleared.

Latch readings at FCF000 (my reading of schematic sheet 3: bit 0 = video cycle, bits 1–15 = A6–A20):

FB81 = video cycle at $1F7000
BB81 = video cycle at $177000
7F8C = CPU cycle at $0FF180

The fault shows up on both video and CPU cycles, which points at the memory timing or address path on the CPU board rather than the RAM.

My suspect list (from the 050-4009-H schematics):

the LS153 row/column muxes U7E, U6E, U5F, U8E
the 74S109 timing flip-flops U3C, U4B, U2B, U3B
the LS260s U2C and U3D
U1C (LS169), U1D (LS138), U1E (74S132)
the discrete 20.375 MHz oscillator (Q1, Q2, Y1)

I can't probe or use freeze spray while it runs, since the card cage is closed. Next step is a diode-mode comparison of every pin on those chips, my board against the XL's spare board.

Questions: has anyone seen this on a 2/10 board*? Is there a known weak part, such as the S109s or the oscillator? Is there a better test than the diode comparison?

*IIRC All Lisas use the same CPU board right?

Anyone have one of the re-engineered CPU Board PCB's that you want to sell??

Thanks!!!

Title: Re: Lisa 2/10: SYSTEM ERROR 10590 that follows one CPU board. Suggestions?
Post by: smwash02 on November 16, 2026, 11:30:42 AM
I would put it in service mode and look at the following memory locations:

186, 270, 27C, 27D ( from Sunder.net (https://lisafaq.sunder.net/single.html). I used it when fixing one of my memory boards. )

Those will tell you the memory it sees and where it sees the memory parity errors to see which section of the parity is failing.

That might give a clue for sections you can reduce your search area to.

I did a run of the CPU, IO, Mainboard, 2MB RAM, DAC, Parallel, keyboard, PROM, COP, etc a couple month ago.

I've got one fully recreated Lisa going. One other recreation CPU board is giving me some troubles, but I've also got 2 bare boards left.

I think I know what's wrong with my other CPU board -- I think I got a batch of defective caps. Measuring each cap I put in my working board I found several out of spec.

Some Photos (https://imgur.com/a/jHUVJWg)

Yes, Lisa CPU and Memory boards can be moved from 2/5s and 2/10s. Mainboard and IO are different.
Title: Re: Lisa 2/10: SYSTEM ERROR 10590 that follows one CPU board. Suggestions?
Post by: bmwcyclist on November 16, 2026, 11:41:23 AM
Thanks!

I looked those up in the boot ROM listing: $186-1A5 are the ROM's memory test results, $270 the parity error address it finds, $27C/$27D the parity chip row and column. Those get filled when the error happens during the ROM's own test.

My machine passes the thorough startup test and only bombs later under LOS, so the error latch at FCF000 has been my main clue, but I'll check them after a cold boot.

A few questions about your recreated boards: whose CPU board design did you use, and does it pass LisaTest, including the error/parity logic tests?
Title: Re: Lisa 2/10: SYSTEM ERROR 10590 that follows one CPU board. Suggestions?
Post by: smwash02 on November 16, 2026, 11:56:48 AM
When I had my parity issue it would 90%+ of the time pass the ROM memory tests, but the parity errors were still there in service mode. I only knew because MacWorks would load and LOS wouldn't with the same error you got.

If you do a 'reset' vs poweroff/on and go into service mode after the failure does it not show its error still? If not, that's a pretty tough issue to dig into. I'd look into editing LOS to dump those locations when it bombs out.

I'm only aware of one CPU board that's been opened up -- WarMech's -- here on GitHub (https://github.com/warmech/lisa-hardware/tree/main/CPU%20Card). I used a 4 pin 20MHz Osc vs a 20.37504MHz or the original clock circuitry with the resistor/osc/transistor network. I also selected 47pF for C43, there seems to be confusion about its value and it's what others went with over the one on the warmech schematic.

Per his message on lisa-hardware (https://github.com/warmech/lisa-hardware) the CPU board fails LisaTest. It's on my list to debug, but haven't made it there yet.

That said, it's run my Windows 3.1 port, LOS, MacWorks, Workbench, some games I've written without any issues. I'm pretty curious to know why it fails just that test and what it's testing. I've not run the test myself yet.
Title: Re: Lisa 2/10: SYSTEM ERROR 10590 that follows one CPU board. Suggestions?
Post by: bmwcyclist on November 16, 2026, 01:43:25 PM
Quote from: smwash02 on November 16, 2026, 11:56:48 AMWhen I had my parity issue it would 90%+ of the time pass the ROM memory tests, but the parity errors were still there in service mode. I only knew because MacWorks would load and LOS wouldn't with the same error you got.

If you do a 'reset' vs poweroff/on and go into service mode after the failure does it not show it error still? If not, that's a pretty tough issue to dig into. I'd look into editing LOS to dump those locations when it bombs out.

Thanks, that's very helpful. I'll try the reset-then-service-mode check the next time it bombs and post what $186 and $270–27D show. Your C43 note is interesting too: I'm comparing my board against a known-good spare and will check what value is fitted on each. If you do get to the bottom of the LisaTest failure on warmech's board, I'd love to hear what it was.
Title: Re: Lisa 2/10: SYSTEM ERROR 10590 that follows one CPU board. Suggestions?
Post by: sigma7 on November 16, 2026, 02:48:37 PM
Quote from: bmwcyclist on November 16, 2026, 09:01:18 AMMy Lisa 2/10 bombs with SYSTEM ERROR 10590 (memory parity) after anywhere from a few minutes to an hour of use.

All Lisa CPU boards are interchangeable, but there are different revisions. The last revision has the red LED on it. In my experience, they all work the same (see edit below).

I think smwash02's suggested procedure of pressing reset immediately when the error occurs to see if the self-test can provide more detail is a good one. If the error doesn't recur with the first reset, try again a few times. If this technique makes the error even somewhat repeatable, it will make it easier to troubleshoot. If it somehow indicates a specific bit or address range is involved, that's also helpful.

Decades ago, it was rumoured that in the Texas factory, they had to mix and match boards to find combinations that worked. Since then, it seems that complication doesn't arise, so it may have been inaccurate or applied only to prototypes. However, the story comes to mind in situations such as these. ie. is it possible that you have run into a semi-incompatible set of boards that suffer from a timing margin design problem rather than some kind of failure... I dunno.

I doubt the oscillator could cause this problem, as all the circuitry involved is synchronized to it. (Aside: AFAIK, no-one has an explanation for the unusual stock frequency.)

When the +5 power rail is out of spec, some parts do not function as expected (sometimes in very subtle ways), so check that next/again.

For an intermittent problem such as this, it may be triggered by noise or glitches coming from the PSU, or through the power line or data connections from other equipment. If the problem is affected by changing circuits or PSUs or time of day, then checking/replacing the electrolytic filter capacitors on the CPU board might be the solution.

If the problem isn't as simple as power filtering, I'd guess this is likely going to be a time consuming challenge to diagnose, even with fancy equipment (maybe impossible without).

The diode test comparison isn't going to find an out-of-spec timing problem (or so I speculate); it might find a non-functional part in different circumstances. As the various parts involved are generally working, you'll need some kind of instrument that can measure sub-microsecond timing... an oscilloscope or logic analyzer. Even with those, being able to reproduce the problem at will is necessary for efficient troubleshooting.

Good luck!

edits:

Presumably the CPU boards all (appear to me to) work the same because all the critical revision updates were made to early versions. If your problematic CPU board is earlier than Rev "H" then I would apply the applicable changes.

smwash02's comment about the bodge cap ( warmech's "C43") tacked on to U5C-11 might be relevant, as it is somehow related to parity errors (HDER being the parity error signal, and HDMSK being the disable for parity checking). IIRC, it's been 47 pF for all the ones I've examined. If your board doesn't have that capacitor, try adding it. It isn't on the H schematic, and not all boards have it. I'm not aware of the consequences of removing it, but if it has broken off of your board then perhaps you've found them!
Title: Re: Lisa 2/10: SYSTEM ERROR 10590 that follows one CPU board. Suggestions?
Post by: bmwcyclist on November 16, 2026, 08:58:22 PM
Quote from: sigma7 on November 16, 2026, 02:48:37 PMFor an intermittent problem such as this, it may be triggered by noise or glitches coming from the PSU, or through the power line or data connections from other equipment. If the problem is affected by changing circuits or PSUs or time of day, then checking/replacing the electrolytic filter capacitors on the CPU board might be the solution.

edits:

Presumably the CPU boards all (appear to me to) work the same because all the critical revision updates were made to early versions. If your problematic CPU board is earlier than Rev "H" then I would apply the applicable changes.

smwash02's comment about the bodge cap ( warmech's "C43") tacked on to U5C-11 might be relevant, as it is somehow related to parity errors (HDER being the parity error signal, and HDMSK being the disable for parity checking). IIRC, it's been 47 pF for all the ones I've examined. If your board doesn't have that capacitor, try adding it. It isn't on the H schematic, and not all boards have it. I'm not aware of the consequences of removing it, but if it has broken off of your board then perhaps you've found them!

Thanks for the advice! I just placed a DigiKey order.....

I am not quite sure how to tell the rev. I see an ink stamped N (620-0119-N) and on the other side a B stamped in a white box.  Another box says BAR 820-4009-B

If I am reading this correctly it does seem to have all of the "add-ons".



Title: Re: Lisa 2/10: SYSTEM ERROR 10590 that follows one CPU board. Suggestions?
Post by: sigma7 on November 16, 2026, 09:24:33 PM
Now that you ask, I'm not sure how the revision markings on the CPU board are decoded... I've seen a variety of stamps and stickers.

I suggest going through the revision chart on page 1 of the Rev. H schematic to see which items are missing/different.

For example, at Rev F, C8 was changed from 1.0 to 2.2 uF. I can't tell what the value is in your pic... maybe it's picture distortion, but that C8 looks mangled. That's related to the reset circuit, not parity errors.

Probably most of the changes over time are not relevant to the problem at hand, but:

I see 'C43' tacked on to U5C, but it and another small ceramic cap nearby appear to have been damaged... C21 is a glitch filter on the parity error signal HDER... does it look intact or is the coating cracked or chipped?
Title: Re: Lisa 2/10: SYSTEM ERROR 10590 that follows one CPU board. Suggestions?
Post by: smwash02 on November 16, 2026, 10:23:40 PM
sigma7's points are really good and yeah C8 doesn't look that great on your board. Caps around U5/LS279 look a little rough as well.

I have a 2/5 (that I believe is a Lisa 1 conversion) and a 2/10. My 2/10 CPU board seems similar to yours -- It has an 'N' stamped the '-119' and an orange sticker that says 'B' instead of it being written on the white box like yours, but I have an LED on mine. My C8 is 2.2uF for reference if yours isn't legible.

Some things that popped into my head since you seem to have found it follows the CPU card are the following:

1) Cold solder joint. Heat could make it fail after boot at different times from the marginal or disconnected signal/power.
2) Marginal chip in the MMU. see if you can clip a logic analyzer on the A/D pins and make sure everyone is doing things.
3) Marginal SRAM. A stretch, but possible.
4) Dirty edge fingers on the CPU board/socket. Some deoxit and make sure the connector is making good contact.
5) A cap out of spec. Ceramics so rarely fail, but back to Sigma7's point -- the electrolytics on the rails would check off a few of his good suggestions.

Hopefully those give you some steps to try.

I had to swap out an LS244 on mine not long after I picked this system up (2 months ago). It's always something :)